The Two Most Popular Roofing Choices
When homeowners in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware consider roofing options, the decision often comes down to two main choices: metal roofing or asphalt shingles. Both materials have proven track records in our climate, but they serve different needs and budgets. Over our 21 years in business, we’ve installed thousands of both types and can help you understand which option makes the most sense for your home.
This decision impacts your home for decades, affecting everything from energy costs to maintenance requirements. Let’s break down the key differences to help you make an informed choice.
Initial Cost Comparison
The upfront cost difference between metal roofing and asphalt shingles is significant. Asphalt shingles typically cost $3-8 per square foot installed, while metal roofing ranges from $8-16 per square foot. For an average 2,000 square foot roof, this means asphalt might cost $6,000-16,000, while metal could run $16,000-32,000.
However, cost per square foot only tells part of the story. The total cost of ownership includes maintenance, energy savings, and replacement timing, which can shift the value equation significantly over time.
Lifespan and Durability
Asphalt Shingle Lifespan
Quality asphalt shingles from CertainTeed typically last 20-30 years in our Mid-Atlantic climate. Premium architectural shingles can approach 35-40 years with proper maintenance. Weather events, proper installation, and regular maintenance significantly impact actual lifespan.
Metal Roof Longevity
Metal roofs regularly last 40-70 years, with some installations exceeding 80 years. They resist weather damage better than asphalt and maintain their protective qualities longer. This extended lifespan often makes metal roofing more cost-effective over time, especially for homeowners planning to stay in their homes long-term.
Weather Performance in Our Region
Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware experience challenging weather conditions that test roofing materials. Both options perform well, but in different ways.
Storm Resistance
Metal roofs excel in high winds, often rated for 140+ mph gusts compared to 110-130 mph for premium asphalt shingles. Metal also resists hail damage better, though modern impact-resistant shingles have significantly improved hail performance.
Snow and Ice Handling
Metal roofs shed snow and ice more effectively due to their smooth surfaces and heat conduction properties. This reduces ice dam formation, a common problem in our region. Asphalt shingles can handle snow loads well but may be more susceptible to ice dam damage without proper attic ventilation.
Energy Efficiency Comparison
Energy efficiency has become a major consideration for homeowners concerned about utility costs and environmental impact.
Metal Roof Energy Benefits
Metal roofs reflect solar heat effectively, reducing cooling costs by 10-25%. They work particularly well with radiant barrier systems and can qualify for Energy Star ratings. In summer, metal roofs can be 50+ degrees cooler than asphalt surfaces.
Asphalt Shingle Options
Cool roof asphalt shingles with reflective granules can provide energy savings similar to metal. CertainTeed offers several Energy Star-rated shingle lines that reflect more heat than standard products. However, these benefits typically don’t match metal roofing performance.
Aesthetic Considerations
Asphalt Shingle Variety
Asphalt shingles offer the widest range of colors, textures, and styles. From basic 3-tab to premium designer lines that mimic slate or wood, shingles work with virtually any architectural style. They provide the traditional look most homeowners expect.
Metal Roofing Styles
Modern metal roofing comes in many styles beyond the traditional standing seam. Metal shingles, tiles, and panels can mimic asphalt, slate, wood, or clay while providing metal’s performance benefits. Color options have expanded significantly, though they’re still more limited than asphalt.
Maintenance Requirements
Asphalt Shingle Care
Asphalt shingles require regular inspection and occasional repairs. Common maintenance includes replacing damaged shingles, cleaning gutters, and ensuring proper ventilation. Most homeowners can handle basic maintenance, though professional inspections are recommended annually.
Metal Roof Maintenance
Metal roofs need minimal maintenance beyond annual cleaning and inspection. Fastener checks and sealant replacement may be needed every 10-15 years. While maintenance is less frequent, it often requires professional service due to safety and technical considerations.
Installation Considerations
Both materials require skilled installation, but they present different challenges. Asphalt shingles are more forgiving during installation and repairs. Metal roofing requires specialized knowledge and tools but offers superior long-term performance when properly installed.
We’re certified installers for both material types, ensuring your roof performs as designed regardless of which option you choose. Our professional installation team has extensive experience with both metal and asphalt systems.
Resale Value Impact
Both options can enhance home value, but in different ways. Quality asphalt shingles provide solid value and broad market appeal. Metal roofing often commands premium pricing due to its longevity and energy efficiency, though market acceptance varies by area.
Making Your Decision
Choose asphalt shingles if you prioritize lower upfront costs, prefer traditional aesthetics, plan to move within 20 years, or want the widest selection of styles and colors.
Consider metal roofing if you plan to stay long-term, want maximum durability and energy efficiency, live in an area prone to severe weather, or prefer minimal maintenance requirements.
Professional Evaluation
The right choice depends on your specific situation, including budget, home design, long-term plans, and personal preferences. Our team provides detailed comparisons that consider all these factors plus your home’s structural requirements and local climate conditions.
We offer samples, cost analyses, and performance projections for both options, helping you make a decision based on complete information rather than assumptions.
Ready to explore your roofing options? Contact us today for a free consultation. We’ll help you determine whether metal roofing or asphalt shingles provide the best solution for your home and family.
Related Reading
- Choosing the Right Roofing Materials: A Homeowners Guide
- 2025s Top Rated Shingles
- Asphalt Shingle Lifespan
- Roof Replacement Frequency
For detailed specifications and industry standards on roofing materials, the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) offers trusted technical guidance and product information.
